Our
Menu //
Take a look at our extensive breakfast and lunch menu, or explore our espresso bar and specialty drinks! Eat in our dining area or call in a takeout order.
Favorites
What We're Known For //
$3.95
Seneca Sunrise Sandwich
Toasted white or wheat bread with mayo, piled high with crispy bacon, smoked ham, fresh eggs and your choice of American, provolone, or Swiss cheese.
$6.75
Skipper Combo
Premium smoked ham, turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese and tomatoes grilled between crispy artisan bread polished off with mayo.
$6.50
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Shredded chicken breast tossed in Chef Lerman’s fiery chipotle sauce, mayo, and blue cheese, served in a Southwestern wrap with provolone cheese & lettuce. Served warm!
Breakfast
Seneca Sunrise Sandwich / $3.95
Toasted white or wheat bread with mayo, piled high with crispy bacon, smoked ham, fresh eggs and your choice of American, provolone, or Swiss cheese.
Breakfast Burrito / $3.95
Sausage, scrambled eggs, and cheese wrapped in a tortilla, served with mild salsa.
Sausage Gravy & Biscuits / $3.95
Old fashioned peppered sausage gravy served over our flaky, homemade biscuits.
Breakfast Specials
MONDAY & SATURDAY ONLY
Breakfast Quiche / $3.95
A savory, rich slice of quiche served with a side of Stoltzfus Dairy yogurt, topped with our homemade granola.
THURSDAY & FRIDAY ONLY
BACON CHEDDAR SCRAMBLE / $3.95
Smoked bacon and hash browns stacked with fresh scrambled eggs and creamy cheddar cheese, baked to perfection.
Breakfast Panini / $5.50
Our signature artisan bread topped with eggs; your choice of bacon, ham, or sausage; sautéed peppers & onions, and provolone cheese then grilled until crispy!
Baked Oatmeal / $3.95
Classic, family recipe of baked oatmeal topped with fruit, and served with a side of milk or yogurt.
Yogurt Parfait / $3.95
Creamy, all natural, high protein Stoltzfus Dairy vanilla yogurt layered with strawberries and blueberries then sprinkled with our homemade granola.
Toast / $1.00
Housemade white or wheat bread toasted and topped with butter, strawberry jelly or fresh ground peanut butter. (1 slice)
Grilled Panini
CHEESESTEAK / $7.50
Thinly sliced and grilled NY strip steak between slices of housemade artisan bread with sautéed peppers & onions and American cheese.
GREEN LEAF / $6.75
Oven roasted chicken breast, provolone cheese, spinach, onions, and green peppers drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette on housemade artisan bread.
Pepperjack / $6.75
Turkey, pepperjack cheese, green peppers, spinach and tomatoes on housemade artisan bread with roasted chipotle mayo.
Turkey Pesto / $6.75
Turkey, provolone cheese and tomato grilled between housemade artisan bread and slathered with mayo and basil pesto.
Skipper Combo / $6.75
Premium smoked ham, turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese and tomatoes grilled between crispy artisan bread polished off with mayo.
Wildwood / $6.75
Quality roast beef on housemade artisan bread with provolone cheese, sautéed peppers & onions, drizzled with Italian dressing.
Gourmet Wraps
Cajun Chicken Wrap / $6.50
Oven roasted chicken breast with provolone cheese, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, and lettuce, smothered with creamy ranch and smoldering chipotle on a Southwestern wrap. Deliciously spicy!
Buffalo Chicken Wrap / $6.50
Shredded chicken breast tossed in Chef Lerman’s fiery chipotle sauce, mayo, and blue cheese, served in a Southwestern wrap with provolone cheese & lettuce. Served warm!
Club Wrap / $6.50
Premium smoked ham, all natural turkey, and smoked bacon with lettuce, tomato, and mayo, in a whole wheat wrap.
Greek Wrap / $6.50
Oven roasted chicken breast with spinach, green peppers, black olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta cheese, and sour cream. Drizzled with Italian dressing and wrapped in a garlic pesto wrap. Juicy & flavorful!
Farmstand Wrap / $6.50
A spinach wrap filled with cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, black beans, hummus and your choice of Garlic Expressions dressing or balsamic vinegar. A great vegan option!
Fresh Subs
12 inch $7.75 / 6 inch $4.50
Sub Roll:
cheesy italian, white or wheat
Meat
turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, capicola, ham or bacon
Cheese
american, cheddar, pepperjack, provolone or swiss
Toppings
lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, green peppers, cucumber or pickles
Dressing
mayo, italian, mustard (hot, honey, regular or sweet), olive oil, caesar, ranch, horseradish
Fresh Sandwiches
Whole $4.75 / Half $3
Switch to Gluten Free Roll for $1.25 upcharge
Chicken Salad
white or wheat bread with chicken salad, lettuce and tomato
Tuna Salad
white or wheat bread with tuna salad, lettuce and tomato
BLT
toasted white or wheat bread with smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo
Build Your Own
Build your own sandwich from our sub list above! (excludes cheesy italian bread)
Fresh Salad
Whole $5.50 / Side $3.50
with protein $6.50 / $4.00
Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce topped with shredded parmesan, ripe olives, home-style croutons and caesar dressing.
Spinach Salad
fresh spinach topped with sliced onions, dried cranberries, cashews, feta cheese and poppyseed dressing.
Chef Salad
Spinach, romaine lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, green peppers, cucumbers, cranberries, cashews or pumpkin seeds
Protein
roasted chicken, bacon or hummus
Cheese
shredded parmesan, crumbly bleu or feta
Dressing
ranch, italian, balsamic, poppyseed, sweet & sour, bleu cheese, caesar, garlic expressions
Housemade Soups
Bowl $3.50 / Cup $2.19
bowl served with a dinner roll
Cheddar Potato & Ham Chowder
Soup of the Week
Housemade Sides
Housemade Coleslaw / $2.25
Housemade Macaroni Salad / $2.25
Housemade Potato Salad / $2.25
Grilled Cheese / $4
PB&J / $4
Ham & Cheese Rollups / $4
Chicken Nuggets / $4
Hot Coffee
Coffee 12oz / $1.50 16oz / $1.75
Americano 12oz / $2.50 16oz / $2.95
Cappuccino 12oz / $2.75 16oz / $3.25
Espresso doubleshot / $1.50
Latte 12oz / $2.75 16oz / $3.25
Red Eye 12oz / $2.50 16oz / $2.95
Cold Coffee
Iced Coffee 16oz / $2.50 24oz / $2.95
Iced Latte 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Blended Latte 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Mocha Java 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Extra Shot:
Espresso $0.50
Flavor $0.25
Hot Drinks
Chai Latte 12oz / $2.75 16oz / $3.25
Hot Chocolate 12oz / $2.25 16oz / $2.75
Hot Tea 12oz / $1.50 16oz / $1.70
Steamer 12oz / $2.25 16oz / $2.75
Cold Drinks
House Lemonade 16oz / $2.25 24oz / $2.75
Iced Chai Latte 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Iced Tea 16oz / $2.25 24oz / $2.75
Fruit Smoothies
Mango 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Peach 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Pina Colada 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Raspberry 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Strawberry 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Wildberry 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Yogurt Smoothies
Peach Yogurt 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Tropical Yogurt 16oz / $3.50 24oz / $3.95
Join
Get Menu Updates
Each month, we update our specials. Sign up to recieve an email with the new specials, as well as the soups we currently have on the menu!
Business Info
We Can't Wait to See You!
Monday to Saturday
7am – 4pm
Sunday
CLOSED
Call Us
(315) 536-0836
Visit Us
3173 Route 14A, Penn Yan NY 14527
Email Us
info@oakleafcafe.com