315-536-0836 info@oakleafcafe.com

New American Cafe

Tasty      Food

Committed to serving tasty food with cheery service and consistent quality, our robust menu of breakfast and lunch items is offered alongside a full espresso bar. We have something for everyone!


M – S: 7am – 4pm


3173 Route 14A
Penn Yan NY 14527                (located inside Oak Hill Bulk Foods)

Since 2009

About Oak Leaf Cafe //

What started as an expansion of Oak Hill Bulk Foods, our cafe has grown massively over the past years. Our commitment to customer care and quality food has not changed since the beginning. 

Tasty Food

Our rich Mennonite background influences how we cook and bake around here. We value food that is filling, has good flavor and is fresh made. 

Fresh Ingredients

Using produce that has been grown here in the farmland area of the Finger Lakes is a priviledge that we don’t take for granted. 

Cheery Service

Service with a smile always makes food better. We hope you feel welcome and taken care of during your visit here!


Pepperjack Panini
Food Plate


A Fresh Approach to Cafe Food //

Although soup and sandwiches are nothing new, each of the dishes on our menu has been thoughtfully crafted with fresh, local ingredients. We partner with neighboring farms and dairies to provide a meal that will exceed your expectations.

Visit Our Location

Located in the rolling farmland between Seneca and Keuka Lake, in the Finger          Lakes region of upstate New York.


Tasty Food,
Consistent Quality,  Cheery Service //

Baked Oatmeal


We are firm believers that breakfast is the most important meal in your day. That’s why we have a hearty offering of breakfast foods that will fill you up, including sandwiches, panini, and baked oatmeal.

BLT Wrap


Lunch doesn’t have to be boring. Our menu is full of fun lunch offerings that are sure to pique your interest and your tastebuds. Order a savory sandwich, housemade soup, or a wholesome salad.

Iced Latte

Espresso Bar

There’s so much to love about our espresso bar. Our coffee is roasted in-house so you get the freshest brew. We serve everything from lattes to hot chocolate and smoothies.


What We’re Known For //


Seneca Sunrise Sandwich

Toasted white or wheat bread with mayo, piled high with crispy bacon, smoked ham, fresh eggs and your choice of American, provolone, or Swiss cheese.

Seneca Sunrise Sandwich
Skipper Combo Panini


Skipper Combo

Premium smoked ham, turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese and tomatoes grilled between crispy artisan bread polished off with mayo.


Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Shredded chicken breast tossed in Chef Lerman’s fiery chipotle sauce, mayo, and blue cheese, served in a Southwestern wrap with provolone cheese & lettuce. Served warm!

Buffalo Chicken Wrap


Raving Reviews

We’re grateful for each of you who have left us awesome reviews. Take a look at a few we’ve gotten below!

A Place for Little Sprouts to Grow

My family LOVES Oak Hill and the cafe. The coffee is delicious, the food is great, the ambience tranquil, and the staff polite and personable. The Cafe has a vegan wrap, for those that have special diets. I love that I can do my shopping while I’m waiting, the kids can play on the playground when we are done, and my Dad can opt for chicken bbq on Saturdays during the summer if he wishes. Great place! Highly recommended.”

Karen R.

Been there for lunch many times. Outstanding!! First time for breakfast. It was delicious. Service is fast and the staff is very friendly. Prices very resonable.”

Oak Leaf Cafe

Business Info

We Can’t Wait to See You!

Monday to Saturday

7am – 4pm



Call Us

(315) 536-0836

Visit Us

3173 Route 14A, Penn Yan NY 14527

Email Us